Amazing everything! Love the food and the atmosphere here--great location. One of my local favorites!

A Tasty Treat at The Black Molly Grill! In St. Augustine's charm, where the sea breezes play, The Black Molly Grill is the place to survey! With a menu so tempting, your taste buds will cheer, Each dish is a delight, bringing joy to your year. Step through the doors and you'll feel right at home, With a cozy vibe where good food can roam. From fresh-caught seafood to burgers so grand, Every bite is a treasure, each flavor well planned. Start with a platter of shrimp so divine, With zesty dips and a cocktail that's fine. The fish tacos are crispy, topped with a flair, A burst of delight with each flavorful share! The ambiance buzzes with laughter and light, As friends gather 'round for a wonderful night. The staff is so friendly, with service so bright, They'll make you feel welcome, everything feels right. Indulge in the specials, let your cravings unfurl, From salads to steaks, it's a flavor-filled whirl. And don't miss the desserts, a sweet end to your meal, The homemade delights will make your heart squeal! So if you're in town and your tummy does call, The Black Molly Grill is the best spot of all! With whims and with wonder that dance on your plate, This grill is a gem--you won't have to wait! So gather your pals for a feast full of cheer, At The Black Molly Grill, you'll want to come near! In St. Augustine's warmth, where memories are spun, This delightful restaurant is simply so fun!

Family visiting- dinner at Black Molly. I had the trout so yummy with jasmine rice (my favorite meal). Wife had a salad. Son had fish. Others had the shrimp special. Two for one happy hour drinks. Great food friendly staff. Love this restaurant.

Absolutely delicious meal and Wonderful Experience. First time at this place. Totally packed but we're seated in 15 minutes. Grabbed a cocktail before and it was a generous pour. Our waiter Colin was fabulous. We split a ribeye and crab cake appetizer. They brought the steak already cut and plated separately, each with mashed potatoes and a split Cesar salad. Started with the spinach dip that was yummy too. Ended with crème brûlée Very generous portion that you should share. Our waiter was so attentive but we observed the Most hardworking wait staff throughout the restaurant. Additionally, the twin bus boys, Anthony and Christian NEVER stop!! Great food, great staff, groovy atmosphere. We will be back anytime we're in St Augustine.

We decided to try this place as we have heard good things about it from locals of St Augustine. This place is amazing. We enjoyed the calamari for starters and the bread with butter, warm and soft. Our server explained the menu and specials well. For our main dish, we had ribeye, fish abaco - halibut and datil chicken. The ribeye was seasoned well and cooked to the temp we requested. The halibut was not fishy and the cream sauce complemented the dish. The datil chicken has a kick but not too spicy. Surprisingly, we finished all our food even though the portions were good. This shows we enjoyed our meal. Another place we will frequently visit.

I recently had a fantastic time at Black Molly's new location. Despite the busy parking lot, we were promptly seated on the charming back patio. Our server was friendly and attentive, providing great recommendations. I loved the almond-encrusted rainbow trout so much at lunch that I had to order the dinner portion too--it was just as delicious. We will definitely be back soon!

We met our friend here to grab dinner at the new location. It was great! There is tons of parking and it's easy to get too. Inside it is bright and spacious. They have the same iconic large booths in part of the restaurant that they had prior. Our server was also great! He recommended a dessert, that we will also recommend to you! We did try it and loved it (see pictures)! The mushroom appetizer was delicious and you can't go wrong with any pasta choice either! My staple choices are usually the dátil chicken or one of the fish dishes. We had been going to the old location for years as a family and this new building is even closer to our family home now. We can't wait to come back!

It's our fire time at the new location and we were not dis's appointment. The new place is beautiful. We are inside I got my usual gold salmon and of course it was amazing. My husband got the steak kabobs with broccoli salad and he was very happy. Mellissa was our awesome server she was excellent. We were very happy with our 1st experience at the new location.

So, we started off on an EXTREMELY bad foot here. Went in around 5 and was told about an hour's wait. No big deal because that is what we expected. However, we literally watched a waitress sit someone who they had a relationship with despite the fact that they hadn't waited at all or even put their name in. Poor practice, especially when all of us waiting had to witness it. Inside is comfortable and laid back. There's a bar inside and they had the playoff game on so that was a win. That being said, we'll get to the actual review. We started with the stuffed mushrooms. They were really yummy! Don't do it if you don't like lemon though, as they are more lemony than buttery. If you like lemon, get the bread now! The Caesar salad was the perfect size - nothing overly special, but good (same with the bread.) We ordered 2 entrees: a ribeye and a filet. Both were cooked perfectly and cut like butter! Just amazing. Clearly, you will not go wrong with a steak here. Polished it off with a piece of chocolate cake. Better than amazing. Overall, the food made up for the walk in experience.